

By Professor Venansius Baryamureeba, Former Presidential Candidate
Challenges facing the 2021 Presidential Election and Managing Presidential Election Expectations and TRansition: Winning a Presidential Election requires high level planning, organization and sophistication. Among the current Presidential candidates only one is a master of the three. Some of the things that happen before and during an election cycle are planned and organised with sophistication as part of a winning strategy. The question one should ask is whether they lead to a free and fair election? As per article 104 (2) & (3) of the Uganda Constitution it takes a maximum of 40 days after declaration of the Presidential Election results for the supreme court to declare its findings i.e. to issue its ruling on any presidential petition lodged with it. But also article 104(6) of the Constitution provides that where an election is annulled, a fresh election shall be held within twenty days from the date of the annulment. In 2011 and 2016 Presidential Elections were held on the 18th of February. So in 2021 why was the Presidential election date brought forward to 14th January yet its amidst COVID-19 and candidates were required to meet the electorates in small groups instead of having big campaign rallies? The current Presidential term will end in May 2021 and so the Electoral Commission could have held this election in February / March 2021 or it could have nominated the candidates much earlier than November 2020 to give them enough time to campaign. The Ministry of Health issued a statutory instrument ‘’Public Health (Control of COVID-19) Rules, 2020’’ to regulate public meetings including political rallies and the President used the same to issue presidential directives to regulate mass meetings including political rallies that would later regulate him as a Presidential Candidate. Why did the Electoral Commission opt to go by standard operating procedures (SOPs) under a cabinet statutory instrument instead of going to a multiparty parliament to have a law enacted that would have regulated the political campaigns in this era of COVID-19 pandemic? A law enacted by Parliament would have provided a regulatory environment and mechanisms that would have enabled the candidates to reach the electorate but also kept the candidates in check. The Supreme Court in its ruling on the 2016 Presidential Election Petition issued wide ranging reforms that had to be addressed through legislation by Parliament and the Electoral Commission proceeded with its roadmap to conduct 2021 Presidential Elections before these reforms were undertaken claiming that the constitution under which the supreme court gave its ruling gives it strict deadlines within which to conduct presidential elections. What shall the supreme court do when its brought to its attention that the 2021 presidential elections were conducted without addressing the issues it raised in its own ruling? Will it opt to issue other orders and reforms or it will nullify the 2021 Presidential 2021 on this ground alone to ensure that other arms of government comply with lawful orders of the supreme court whenever issued? The Electoral Commission issued a campaign roadmap to guide presidential campaigns. Candidates submitted campaign programmes that indicated when they would be in various districts and the Electoral Commission approved these programmes. Now that some candidates cannot even drive through districts, go to community radios or physically meet their agents in these districts, how will this affect the outcome of the 2021 Presidential Election? Should the Electoral Commission have postponed the election to February or March 2021 and allowed candidates more time to campaign in all these districts and still use the same ballot papers since the candidates would have remained the same? Any Presidential Candidate can be voted President. It’s up to the electorate. To what extent has the broad day demeaning of Presidential Candidates affected the whole electoral exercise and the outcome of the 14th January 2021 election? Looking at pictures of a toothless Presidential Candidate Katumba tussling it out with the police leaves one with sorrow. Are we likely to see disruptions on voting day or even death of civilians during and after the elections as a result of involvement of less trained crime preventors in the electoral process? Do the Presidential Candidates have a national voters register and the distribution of voters by region, district, constituency and polling station? It is estimated that the national voters register for the 2021 Presidential Election has 17.7 Million voters and this implies that the average number of voters per district is approx. 130,000. So a Presidential Candidate who meets 13,000 voters at a rally in a district just interfaces with just 10% of the voters. So how is such a presidential candidate interfacing with the remaining 90% in this era of COVID-19 pandemic? Presidential Candidates are supposed to use their own resources to conduct campaigns. Even for door to door campaigns, means of transport and human resources are key. The state security agencies closely working with the Electoral Commission are said to have confiscated vehicles and other properties of candidates and detained campaign teams of some presidential candidate (s). Also, it’s now clear that on voting day more than 40% of the registered voters will be seeing the candidates on the ballot paper for the first time since not every voter has access to TV or internet. Also we know that most candidates’ posters are not in the communities. What implication will this have on the outcome of the 14th January 2021 presidential election? It’s a fact that where Presidential Candidates have fielded parliamentary and local council candidates, their campaign messages have continued to be disseminated to the public even after they left. This is likely to enable them reach more voters through ground teams. When I look at the Parliamentary, Local Council (LC)5, LC3 and Mayoral map apart from National Resistance Movement (NRM), no other candidate / party has covered more than 30% of the electoral constituencies i.e. has fielded more than 30% of the candidates in these positions. Someone will say Presidential Elections can be won without any candidates at Parliamentary and lower levels campaigning for the presidential candidate? This can only happen where the Presidential Candidate has been able to use all campaign channels to reach all the voters across the country. Apart from news on radios and newspapers, very few presidential candidates have paid for commercial space or airtime to boost their campaigns. Even the Electoral Commission has not provided any airtime on the national broadcaster, which it should have especially that it unilaterally varied the campaign programmes of the candidates without consultations with the candidates.It’s the mandate of the Electoral Commission with or without the candidates polling agents to conduct free and fair elections devoid of vote rigging. In Africa and elsewhere in the world the rigging takes place through mainly alteration of declaration forms issued at polling stations, multiple voting, voting by non-voters and ghosts casting votes. These irregularities will occur at some of the polling stations in the January 2021 elections. Recently, I had a Bishop say on TV that politicians should not steal elections because it’s a sin. Well even in America, President Trump is on record asking Georgia Secretary of State to get him more votes and declare him winner. Many presidential candidates are planning to rely on goodwill of Ugandans to vote for them and also stay behind and guard their votes including securing declaration forms. Will this succeed? I can clearly state that other than relying on other candidates who are contesting for parliamentary seats, its only President Museveni and Hon. Kyagulanyi that will deploy additional polling agents. Others know that they don’t have many votes to protect. Will each candidate ( President Museveni / Hon. Kyagulanyi) cover all polling stations in the country? Your guess is as good as mine. Despite the above issues and others I have not mentioned, the election is on and presidential candidates are participating because they have accepted that all these issues are not of material significance to alter the outcome of the election. Otherwise why would one want to participate in an election where the results are already known or where the process would lead to a rigged election? All key issues being raised on the process preceding the 2021 election just like the previous elections point to the fact that, as long as President Museveni is on the presidential ballot paper, nobody should expect a level playing field. But the election results will always be declared by the Electoral Commission. Despite any shortcomings, for any presidential election petition, the declaration by the supreme court is a simple majority decision and in most cases, the supreme court will uphold the declaration by the Electoral Commission as it has happened several times in the past. Also, the cost of repeating a presidential election is so high that most Ugandans are comfortable with the outcome regardless of any shortcomings. So, in the 2021 Presidential Election, what should we expect? First, I have seen organized crowds in many parts of central region including Kampala welcoming President Museveni amidst COVID-19 but he will get very few votes in some of these places. I also saw Hon. Kyagulanyi having huge crowds in western Uganda including my home district of Ibanda. Ugandans are very hospitable people and they welcome everybody. So it does not mean that when I come to your rally that I will vote for you. When I followed up with a sample of those who attended Hon. Kyagulanyi rally in Ibanda, the responses were very telling. The audience he addressed in Ibanda comprised of genuine supporters, those who attend any rally regardless of who the candidate is, those who came to see Kyagulanyi the artist, whose who came to see the Presidential Candidate with a security convoy bigger than that of President Museveni, those who came expecting entertainment, those who came expecting handouts like drinks or money and those who were mobilized by some NRM cadres in Ibanda to scare President Museveni to release campaign funds. But just like Museveni will get few votes in Kampala, Hon Kyagulanyi will get very few votes in Ibanda. This trend will be repeated in strongholds of each candidate. As I said in early November 2020, President Museveni and Hon. Kyagulanyi will share 90% of the valid votes cast on 14th January 2021 and all the other candidates will share the remaining 10%. If we divide Uganda into four regions, the two regions with many electorates are Western Region and Central region and a candidate that wants to win the Presidential Election must win the combined vote of these two regions. Hon. Kyagulanyi will not get a block vote in central region but will defeat President Museveni in central region. However, President Museveni will not get less than 30% of the central region vote. On the other hand, President Museveni will get a block vote in Western region. Hon. Kyagulanyi will get less than 10% of the votes in western region. Gen. Muntu and Gen Tumukunde have been written off in western region and Hon Amuriat has no votes at all in the western region. In Eastern region, it’s going to be stiff competition between Hon. Kyagulanyi and President Museveni and the margin between the two candidates is likely to be less than 7%. President Museveni will win northern region with at least 60% of the valid votes. The issues of Buganda and Northern Uganda that affected politicians from these regions in the past still exist in both regions. So, Hon. Kyagulanyi coming from central region should not raise his hopes of getting many votes in Northern Uganda. Looking at how Hon. Kyagulanyi has gained momentum and in some cases aided by tactical mistakes by NRM handlers, if elections were postponed as proposed by Inter-Religious Council, a re-run between him and Museveni would be a possibility as other candidates would have also gained ground. But looking at the current situation, there won’t be a re-run. On 14th January 2021, I predict President Museveni will win by 60.3% and Hon Kyagulanyi will get 29.7% and this prediction has a 5% margin of error. Hon. Kyagulanyi will emerge out of this election much stronger and National Unity Platform (NUP) will sweep mayoral and other local council elections across central region including Kampala on top of taking up the Leader of Opposition in Parliament slot since it will have more MPs than any other opposition party in Parliament. If NRM is to slow down Hon. Kyagulanyi’s momentum before 2026, it has to go back to the drawing board and strategize. The issues of high public expenditure and poor social services coupled with corruption and high unemployment among the youth won’t just be talked away. They have to be addressed. President Museveni cannot keep so many old people (60 and above) in the category of retired in key positions in Cabinet as the youth think that there are not able to appreciate and address their issues. That’s why they are yearning for Hon. Kyagulanyi whom they think will have a young Cabinet. President Museveni needs a Kibaki Cabinet i.e. a high performing cabinet as he rests and looks for votes. For sure, President Museveni if alive will be on the Presidential ballot in 2026, and so he has to start looking for votes for 2026 starting on 15th January 2021 and his next Cabinet will demonstrate whether he has learnt lessons from this Presidential election. After this election, the Democratic Party (DP) will not have more than 5 MPs in Parliament and will weaken as we head towards 2026. More DP MPs will defect to NUP. Uganda People’s Congress (UPC) is as good as dead. For the case of Alliance for National Transformation (ANT), Gen. Muntu has ran his race and the party needs to move very fast and replace him with Hon. Winnie Kizza in the first quarter of 2021 otherwise it will go into comma. The Forum for Democratic Change (FDC) will definitely emerge weaker out of the 2021 national elections and is at the risk of being wiped out by both NRM and NUP. FDC needs to replace Hon. Amuriat in 2021 by a more vibrant Party President with home or national base if it’s to survive being swallowed by NRM and NUP by 2025. With Hon. With Hon. Kyagulanyi as President of NUP based in Buganda, no other formidable opposition politician can emerge from Buganda. So FDC should write-off Lord Mayor Elias Lukwago as a potential FDC Party President and future presidential candidate. Hope for FDC lies in Hon. Winnie Byanyima or Hon. Nandala Mafabi. Hon. Mafabi can galvanize the eastern region and get more than 60% of the eastern region vote in 2026. On the other hand, Hon. Winnie Byanyima has a national base especially among the women and youth.