U.C.E. 2023: Mbale rural govt aided schools star as heads  speak out on better performance
February 16, 2024
Kibuli: Kakungulu Memorial School UCE Stars Shine On
February 18, 2024
Show all

Opinion: Stop the foolery, Government agencies are not merging any time soon

Wadada Rogers

I have previously written about this sensitive subject wherein I implored government to expedite the process of merging agencies even when some people will lose their jobs. For years now, government has been threatening to merge government agencies. The reason had been to strengthen departments of ministries and make them more functional as opposed to duplication of services where you have a semi- autonomous entity and a department within the ministry more or less doing the same work.

The Minister of Public Service-Muruuli Mukasa is on record for having said the proliferation of agencies had created mandate overlaps and jurisdictional ambiguities among the agencies and if accepted, merging could save the tax payer almost a trillion shillings annually. It is anticipated that atleast 33 government departments and agencies were due to go back to their mother agencies. It is these remarks that prompted the speaker to appoint a committee led by Honourable Byanyima to look into the matter.

The committee was mandated to come up with a report on the proposed merger. Having done their ground work, the committee presented its findings to the House in May, 2022 but as usual it was subjected to the usual bureaucratic tendencies. Almost two years later, the report was abandoned on the shelves of Parliament as it could not be debated pending a response from Muruuli Mukasa- the line Minister.

According to the report, the Committee agreed with the government’s proposals to collapse some agencies and merge others but also called for the retention of several others including but not limited to the Uganda National Roads Authority.The criteria to determine which one was to be retained is what sparked controversy. Since then, there has been a lot of lobbying to have certain agencies retained.

Those advocating for the retention of regulatory agencies in the Agriculture sector argue that the merger will negatively impact on Uganda’s exports to the international market as was the case when Uganda’s tea was affected upon abolition of the Uganda Tea Authority. Those lobbying for the retention of some entities within the agricultural sector argue that it will be reckless to undermine our national regulatory stamps that have attracted premium prices on the international market.

The truth is that in all fairness, there is a need to first scrutinize the Byanyima led committee report as repealing, enacting and/or amending the over 40 Acts would require putting away all parliamentary business if the proposed merger of all the agencies is to see light of day.I don’t think it is practicable to bring all the proposed mergers in an omnibus manner. The process could be done in a haphazard manner resulting into some professional litigants challenging the same in the court of law.

Matters are made worse that each of the 40 entities being proposed for merger has different laws and different sectoral committees of parliament.Pulling down, enacting or amending all these laws must be done in an orderly manner with strict adherence to the known procedures of Parliament.But all said and done, how practical is the minister’s wish, can this be done in the next 2years of this Parliament?

I personally have no doubt that these laws when amended, enacted and/or repealed would go a long way in facilitating an efficient and effective service delivery by delineating the mandates and functions of government agencies and departments. The immediate benefit will be avoiding duplication of mandates and functions; promoting coordinated administrative arrangements, policies and procedures for ensuring the efficient and successful management, financial accounting and budgetary discipline of these agencies and departments. How I wish our leaders can open their inner eyes to see what am seeing.

On February, 8th, 2024, the Prime Minister, Robinah Nabbanja told Parliament that Government had finalized plans to table the Rationalization of Government Agencies (Education Sector) (Amendments) Bill, 2024, the Rationalization of Government Agencies (Internal Affairs Sector) (Amendments) Bill, 2024, the Rationalization of Government Agencies (Natural Resources and Environment Sector) (Amendments) Bill, 2024 as well as the Rationalization of Government Agencies (Works and Transport Sector) (Amendments) Bill, 2024.

However, it appears our leaders are not decided on whether or not to merge these agencies; their fear could be associated with creating a job vacuum for those who have been holding those offices. For example, in November last year, there was an attempt to table the Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2023 that provided for the merger of the Equal Opportunities Commission with the Uganda Human Rights Commission. The MPs questioned why the plan was being executed in piecemeal, an act which points to lack of will or preparedness to face the consequences that come with that decision.

The problem is that these agencies had been given so much power to the extent of determining their own salaries and manage their own affairs. In fact the generous salary structures of the agencies had created salary disparities between employees of the agencies and public officers in the main ministry hence leading to demotivation of human resource in the mainstream public service. No wonder Government is scare of the likely consequences of the merger. My view is that the amendments should include a provision to shield government from having to pay Compensation to terminated employees.

I am one of those who believe that having a political will to merge, mainstreaming and rationalizing agencies, commissions and authorities would reduce public expenditure thereby relieving the Government of the financial drain on its resources and the burden of wasteful administration and expenditure. Sadly our leaders don’t seem to see these benefits as the merger will affect their own relatives.  As usual, the ugly head of nepotism could emerge when it comes to redeploying those deemed very useful.

It is also obvious that the proposed merger will lead to retrenchment of the thousands of employees which has a serious financial implication on the consolidated funds. This therefore means that the minister of public service must find out how many people are going to be dropped, how many are going to be absorbed and how much money will be required for pension and gratuity for those to be retired. 

Given the sensitivity of the matter, it appears the Minister must table one bill at ago to the various committees and defend his decision before moving to table another to the same committee or to a different committee. It is after engaging the various committees that that matter can be brought to the floor of parliament for debate.Whether or not an omnibus approach is adopted to expedite the process, 40 laws are too many to be handled in the remaining time of about 2years by a last Parliament.

We out to recall that to merge these agencies may requires an amendment to the Constitution and to amend the Constitution to rationalize those agencies requires instituting a Constitutional Review Commission, that is a the precedent that stands unchallenged. We cannot forget that a Constitutional Review Commission requires a lot of time to execute their work.  Their findings are also tabled in stages before they can be adopted for debate in the house. So given the numerous plans to amend several provisions of the Constitution, I do not see the process being implemented this term.

When all is said and done, the merger of government agencies and departments will be a contentious subject only good for academics. The desired constitutional amendments are for other reasons intended to entrench them in power. I do not see the willingness for Government to push for the merger of these agencies any time soon. For me, this whole merger game is a debate intended to confuse and convince the funders and civil society organisations. These agencies are here to stay at least until next term.

Wadada Rogers is a commentator on political, legal and social issues. Wadroger @yahoo.ca

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *