Leading financiers to attend global Affordable Housing Conference in Cape Town
October 16, 2019
Museveni records messages calling all to end AIDS by 2030
October 17, 2019
Show all

How Rhino fund Uganda is edging closer to eviction

By Richard Kintu

The contract battle between rhino fund Uganda and its landlord Ziwa Ranchers Limited is one that can pass for a dangerous ping pong affair.

This is simply because it has so far already drawn many twists and turns that both parties are resting their hopes on what court will finally proclaim in regard to the true ownership of the contested sanctuary which is the only home to the only 29 southern white rhinos that Uganda is keeping for herself, Africa’s and the world’s sake.

As reported earlier in these pages, at the centre of the battle is 16,000 acres (or 62 square kilometers) of land at Nakitoma Village in Nakasongola district that Ziwa Ranchers Limited proprietor, Capt. Charles Joseph Roy accuses RFU Executive Director, Angella Genade aka Angie Genade of attempting to grab.  Earlier reports show that Angie decided to move for the possession of the said land after Capt. Roy terminated a 30-year lease that he had given Rhino Fund Uganda to run the conservation efforts for the rhinos.

Rhino fund stuck

On September 30, 2019, RFU was dealt a huge blow when High Court Land Division registrar, Flavia Nabakooza Kalungi, declined to grant Genade an interim order barring Roy through his Ziwa Ranchers from accessing the sanctuary land. In her application arising from Civil Suit no. 804 of 2019, Genade, on behalf of RFU, sought to restrain Roy and his family or his agents from selling, alienating or causing waste to land or in any way altering the status quo of the suit land until the hearing and final determination of the main application.

Court records show that in the main suit, RFU is challenging Roy’s ownership of the suit land and thus want court to evict Genade or cancel RFU’s contract.

In an earlier application in which Genade had also sued Mukwano Group tycoons Amiral Karmali and his wife Rukhsana Karmali; Genade argues that records at the land registry show that the Rhino Sanctuary land actually belongs to the Mukwano moneybags.

Genade further claimed that she had discovered that sometime in 2009, Roy and his wife Daisy who owned 50% shares of the said land respectively transferred their stake to Amiral and his wife Rukhsana Karmali. She avers that the latter couple thus became the bona fide shareholders and directors of Ziwa Ranchers Company.

It is also against the above background that she had sued Capt. Roy and the Karmalis at the high court Civil Division complaining about their attempts to evict her on top of what she calls erroneous cancellation of the URF contract.

Drama would however ensue when she last month struck mukwano group from the suit.

Through her lawyers led by Henry Kirunda, Genade withdrew the case saying she had realized the Karmalis had been erroneously sued. Calling the inclusion of the Mukwano tycoons as an act of “mistaken identity; Genade said they had decided to instead pursue their matter through the High Court Land division, with Capt. Roy as the sole defendant.

Reacting to the request for this withdrawal, both Mukwano and Roy’s lawyers led by Counsel Richard Omongole consented to it but prayed to court to condemn Genade to costs to cover legal fees and related expenses that they had incurred in preparation of the bogus case.

However, Judge Lydia Mugambe granted the withdrawal but saved URF from costs on ground that the withdrawal was timely.

Huge blow

Consequently, the High Court Land Division registrar, Flavia Nabakooza Kalungi scheduled ruling on whether Genade could be granted the interim order for September 30, 2019.

Before Nabakooza, Genade accuses Roy of purported termination of URF’s 30-year contract, which termination was issued on October 16, 2017. Genade further claims that since this termination, Roy has gone on to issue the Fund with continuous eviction threats on top of reaching out to their funders to stop dealing with URF. Genade cited a January 28, 2019 eviction notice that Capt Roy issued her through his lawyers as well as a may 27, 2019 letter which he wrote to the Fund’s donors including UNDP and the European Union to that effect. Genade claims that once roy is allowed to contract the contract, her fund stands to lose out on the immense investment they have put in the facility while the fate of the 29 rhinos and 143 staff will remain unknown.

However, her pleas that day went up in smoke as Nabakooza denied granting her the interim order pending a response from Capt. Roy’s side.

 “I cannot issue an injunction before the other party replies. I, therefore, dismiss the application,” she ruled.  

Ziwa ranchers lawyer Omongole welcomed the ruling, while also vowing to appeal against justice Mugambe’s earlier refusal to grant them damages accruing from Genade’s withdrawal of the Civil Division case.

“We shall appeal against the decision of the Lady Justice because we injected a lot in the case. RFU cannot go court free like that,” Omongole vowed.

Omongole further accused Genade of using delaying tactics to prolong her stay on his client’s land yet she already knows that she is just supposed to leave.

“First of all a contract dispute is a civil rather than a land matter. The attempt by Genade to file it in the land division while also seeking for useless injunctions is nothing short of forum-shopping to prolong the case,” Omongole said. He however vowed that they are determined to fight for what belongs to them until the last drop of their blood and sweat.

Omongole’s words come on the heels of reports that the state house report into this matter was concluded and awaits a final decision by the president who has since met the warring parties. During the first meeting at state house, the presient asked the two parties to amicably resolve the matter for the good of the rhinos as well as investor confidence.

He however noted that while Genade had done good work in multiplying the rhinos, he was aware that the land in contention belongs to Capt. Roy and as such cannot be taken away from him since it is private property. Nevertheless, he deployed state house legal officer hope Kiconco to investigate the matter further.

Genesis

Court documents trace the beginning of this battle to 2002 when Roy, out of undying love to introduce the extinct southern white rhinos to Uganda, entered into a concession agreement with D&D International, a company owned by Genade’s late husband to operate a lodge at the ranch (Amuka Lodge) and also look after the rhinos. In return, D&D was supposed to pay 10% of gross income and 10% from the restaurant to Capt. Roy.

They were also required to pay another 10% for accommodation and 10% from the restaurant as a contribution to the welfare of the rhinos.

However, Roy’s lawyers said that D&D never paid any money to them and proceeded to create another company, Amuka Limited, to run the activities of the lodge.

This prompted Roy to terminate the concession agreement with RFU and D&D in November 2017.

Roy’s lawyer, Omongole revealed that Genade has since reneged on the promises and this forms the core of the current standoff.

Omongole also accuses Genade of signing an illegal agreement with RFU to dodge payment of 10% to RFU, thus creating a conflict of interest.

Following fruitless attempts to recover their own share of the rhino money, Roy’s family learnt Genade had allegedly made inquiries with the Nakasongola district land board with the aim of taking over the sanctuary land.

Genade ran to the Commercial Court’s arbitration department and filed injunctions stopping Roy from terminating her contract.

Thereafter, she immediately put a caveat on the 16,000 acres of land using her company secretary, a one Kamahoro and denied Roy and his family from accessing the land, thereby denying them the right to upgrade their lodge and ranch.

According to Omongole, Genade placed the caveat and attempted to convert her tenancy into a lease, which is a fraudulent act.

Background

According to court documents, Yvonne Vierkaik of RFU in 2012 approached Roy and persuaded him to reintroduce rhinos in Uganda and have them housed at his ranch in Nakasongola.

Subsequently, Roy bought another ranch at Kiryana in Masindi and moved over 7000 animals he had at Nakitooma Ranch in Nakasongola.

Subsequently, Roy built an electric perimeter fence around the entire sanctuary land using proceeds from an international fundraising drive that he spearheaded alongside his daughter Wendy Roy and Yvonne.

Part of the fundraising activities included a boat rowing event from Munyonyo to Mwanza whose entire proceeds were given to RFU to translocation and care of the initial four rhinos from Kenya and another two from the USA.

Roy also constructed all the houses at the sanctuary, drilled boreholes, water dips among other projects at the rhino sanctuary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *