

By Richard Kintu
Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA) Director for Physical Planning, Mr. Atwine Moses Kanuniira, has lately been under fire from members of Parliament sitting on the Committee for Statutory Authorities and State Enterprises (COSASE).
Whereas the invitation to KCCA and subject matter for discussion (seen by our reporter) was clear and specific to responding to the Auditor General queries in his reports for financial years (FY2016/17 and FY2017/18) the subject matter was quickly abandoned to discuss a one Mr. Atwine Moses Kanuniira.
The Second Opinion sought him out for an exclusive interview and below are excerpts.
The Second Opinion (SO): Lately you have been on the hot spot in Parliament and news with queries lingering over your competence and academic credentials. What exactly is the issue that makes COSASE believe you’re not the right man for your current job?
Atwine Moses Kanuniira (AMK)
The issue actually is not about my competence or lack of academic credentials as they term it— Academic credentials at this point in time? That’s laughable! I wish to further submit and affirm here that I have the relevant qualifications and the experience meriting my current appointment, which followed the right procedure. I was duly interviewed and vetted by the Public Service Commission, which is the sole body mandated by Government to vet and recommend one’s competences and suitability for any particular [formal] job in this country.
To be specific, I hold a Master of Science [MSc] in Urban Planning and Management, a Post-Graduate Diploma in Regional Development Planning and Management, a Bachelor’s degree in Social Sciences and several other professional certificates from credible institutions. I have over 23 cumulative years of work experience earned through working with a number of reputable [local and international] organizations. Of the above 23 years, close to seven years [2001-2007] I was teaching Urban and Regional Planning students at Makerere University. I joined KCCA much later in December 2012 as part of the Task Force to support the transformation team to help rescue the city from the mess it was going through. To-date as a result of our effort there is evidence to reckon with by way of the registered progress in the city’s transformation journey in past 7-8 years.
SO: But the general public has been led to believe that you lack the requisite academic qualifications for your office and that’s why buildings and boundary walls are collapsing?
AMK: Such misrepresentation is utterly unfortunate and only serves to confirm the schemes of the protagonists of this malicious probe. I will repeat here that professionally, it is actually my Bachelor’s degree training that inspired/ motivated me to pursue Urban Planning studies at postgraduate level where I obtained a Postgraduate Diploma in Regional Planning and a Master of Science degree in Urban Planning obtained from highly reputable institutions in Ghana and Germany, respectively.
This is a specialized program, open to a multitude of professionals from both developing and developed countries who desire to train in urban planning or/and urban management. This program draws professionals from various fields including economists, social scientists, architects, planners, engineers, medical doctors, and public health specialists, environmentalists among others, who aspire to specialize as urban planners or urban practitioners. So, rather than crucify me for lacking the required information, one needed to do more research about some of these things before mobbing me up in a public court.
SO: Having said the above, I don’t see where the problem came from?
MAK: This issue was tactically introduced under the pretext of revoking rule No 178(b) of the Parliamentary Rules of Procedure, which states that in the event of having any matter of national importance, Parliament or its Committee shall/can first discuss such a matter before (or outside) the pre-scheduled agenda.
The issue raised by Members of Parliament revolved around two recent but isolated incidents of collapsing (dilapidated boundary walls) one at Namirembe Guest House and another at Lohana High School Old Kampala. In both cases, the walls were found to have collapsed as a result of structural failure due to their old age, coupled with poor maintenance, all of which were worsened by the recent heavy rains during the months of April/May 2019. Interestingly they also added the boundary wall that collapsed in Makindye Ssabagabo Municipality, killing almost an entire family, as being under my jurisdiction, yet it is in Wakiso District.
That notwithstanding, my astonishment was the haste of diverting the discussion and manner in which it was handled, which led me to believe that there was some level of ‘undercurrent’ which was well premeditated, rehearsed by some members, given the way I was interrogated during the two hours of the initial sitting.
On the contrary, KCCA reports already indicated that the proprietors of Lohana High School and Namirembe Guest House had been issued the statutory notices by KCCA staff (during their routine inspections) to remove/renovate or demolish the aging and failing walls but in vain. Isolated structural failure of buildings happens everywhere in the world, especially if the subject structures are not attended to by their owners/occupants in a timely manner.
SO: So why didn’t you explain exactly what you just said?
AMK: Before I could explain the circumstances under which the two walls failed and collapsed, they (Committee) seemed prejudiced to conclude and attribute the collapse of the aging boundary walls to my personal qualifications and how I was recruited into the KCCA service. If the above was to be true or hold any meaning and basis for my interrogation, then all Doctors in Mulago or other hospitals who superintend over ailing and dying patients [without recovering] would have been recalled or thrown out of their jobs. On the other hand, I have not heard any traffic police officer [or officials from the Transport Licensing Board] being put on the spotlight to explain their qualifications and training over the many road accidents that happen on a daily, given that they superintend over roads and vehicles in the country.
According to the Public Health Act Cap281 (Building Rule No 18), the approval of any plans of any building or structure does not and shall NOT in any way impose or imply acceptance of any responsibility on the part of the local authority [in this case KCCA or its agents] for the stability or any such structure. The law presupposes that the structural stability or and maintenance of buildings in a sound condition is the responsibility of the owner/occupier and not that of the respective local authority or its agents.
SO: It is said that MPs were angered by you referring to having been appointed by the HE the President. Is that correct?
AMK: Well, I was only responding to the question regarding how I was recruited into KCCA. The KCC Act 2010 sec. 17 and 25 are clear and specific on how and who is responsible for the appointment of the Executive Director and the respective Directors at KCCA. My reference to His Excellency the President was only in accordance with the above law, and nothing else outside that fact. This particular statement was construed by some MPs as being arrogant and defensive. Subsequently, they actually ordered me to give evidence under oath and explain how I was recruited. Shortly after that, I was quickly and summarily detained for close to two hours in the Parliamentary Dungeon in disguise of extracting [General Inquiry File] statements by CIID officers.
SO: So in your opinion, what is the Genesis of this fracas?
AMK: Well, there are several schools of thought suggesting that there has been some power struggles and speculation at KCCA since the departure of the former Executive Director (Dr. Jennifer Ssemakula Musisi) in December 2018. There is information to suggest that my name/person was rumored among the potential candidates being vetted for the highly coveted job of the Executive Director. In case this is true, I wouldn’t be surprised, given my track record of integrity, experience, transparency and being assertive in my work and methods for the past 7(from Dec 2012 to-date) years I have served in the Authority.
There is another school of thought suggesting that I was seen as a potential threat likely to un-do some of the invisible under-goings at KCCA in the event that I became the next Executive Director. This assertion resonates very well with the attention and the manner in which the harassment was orchestrated on my person with a view to bring me down by making baseless allegations. The whole game plan was to cause me; both personal and public dis-reputation after failing to get any corruption case or integrity related cases against my name.
SO: If that’s your honest opinion, then why are there such queries after a whopping seven years on the job? Can we therefore conclude that you are being hounded because of the ensuing power vacuum at KCCA and the subsequent speculation? If so, how do you tie into the whole equation?
AMK: Unfortunately, you are not far from the truth to suggest the former. This is because there’s information to suggest that in singling me out for this probe, its invisible architects aimed at humiliating and character-assassinating me on baseless allegations such that by the time it is wound up, I will be damaged goods. This ferocity is based on some information out there that given my track record at work, there’s great fear that the appointing authority may pick on my name among the propositions for the higher office. And all honesty dictates that if this was a well-intentioned probe then majority of the KCCA management staff at City Hall would have been under a similar probe because they also currently hold offices based on their second or third degrees as a switch/mastery of career from their first degrees. But I will not go into details of that.There are a number of Ugandans and other professionals worldwide who have switched career from one initial qualification to another either at Masters or PhD level. Without prejudice, this is a normal practice and should not be a matter of contention unless there are proven issues related to incompetence or integrity, which was never the case.
In fact it is on record, [with all due respect] the former Director of Physical Planning at the Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development, Mr. Severino Kastigaire (now retired) and the current Director, Physical Planning Mr. Vincent Byendeimira, their first degrees are not necessarily in “physical planning” as a matter of nomenclature, but rather their second degrees are. These two gentlemen and of course the Ministry of Lands at large, were very instrumental in the establishment of the current Bachelor’s degree course in Urban and Regional Planning at Makerere University. One would suppose that these are the line sector authorities’ best suited to interpret the nomenclatures between “physical” and “urban planning”.
SO: Given this background, why do your aggressors fault you for lacking physical planning knowledge? We actually saw one of the probe committee members saying your lack of physical planning foundations and suggesting it is the reason structures have collapsed in the city?
AMK: Unfortunately I can’t stop anyone from saying whatever they want to say about me. My only solace is the fact and conviction that my academic qualifications are authentic and speak heavily for themselves while at the same time I went through the elaborate recruitment process. But that aside, the global practice is that physical planning is just a component of urban planning, so it is illogical to argue that an urban planning expert of my caliber can lack physical planning knowledge— this is akin to imputing that say [with all due respect]; a cartographer is more knowledgeable than a surveyor when it comes to handling land matters.
One may argue that the interpretation of these concepts [physical vis urban planning] varies from one country to another but I’m very sure Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for these disciplines is perhaps the same. It is, therefore, very important that when in doubt about someone’s qualifications then the best thing would have been to do thorough research and due diligence rather than jumping into character-assassination schemes. There was, for instance, a chance to crosscheck my papers with the German or/and Ghanaian Embassies in Uganda to prove authenticity of my credentials and their interpretation, but that wasn’t the case and as such it makes the whole attack on my person very suspicious.
SO: But your pursuers are also motivated by claims that the law was flouted in your recruitment?…
AMK: That’s an excuse that any one can’t buy. Let’s not confuse anyone here: the truth is that there was no law flouted because whereas the position of Director Physical Planning is statutory; an advert or job description on which they based my crucifixion is not statutory. The latter is rather a moving target which can possibly change 100 times according to the availability of the sought personnel, the scope of work or other requirements at the time of the assignment. Statutory qualifications are usually well defined in law or stipulated in the Constitution. But in this case what constitutes the law is the office and not the job descriptions.
SO: There are rumors suggesting that there were large sums of money that exchanged hands between KCCA and some Committee members to facilitate the ugly incident that happened in Parliament on that day. What do you have to say about that?
MAK: Well, the good thing you said it is a rumor. So I can’t verify or comment on that. But in case your source of information can prove that it happened, I can’t be surprised.
SO: The above notwithstanding, can you therefore enumerate some of your key achievements during your tenure in office so far?
AMK: There has definitely been a number of reforms during my leadership in the physical planning directorate in general, but to mention a few. Regarding the planning of the city, some of the key areas include implementing the Kampala Physical Development Plan 2013 with respect to re-planning some of the key precincts beginning with Kololo, Nakasero, Mulago and Makerere, out of a total of 29 precincts.
This project is still ongoing with a view to mitigate the development pressure facing these inner city precincts. The reasoning is that since these four areas are fairly planned, and they continue to risk ‘unregulated urban renaissance or development invasion’ whereby everyone that gets reasonable investment capital wants to run to settle in these areas. This is a good idea, but it needs to be planned and regulated as a matter of priority.
Secondly, under my tenure, you will notice that Kampala has an increasingly growing trend of new, modern, authentic high-rise buildings of between 10 and 25 stories as opposed to what we used to have between 1 to 4 levels. I purposed to roll out this policy with a view to densify the inner city’s space well aware that the land is inelastic, thus the need to optimize its market value as per recommendation in the KPDP 2013.
Still, under my leadership, we initiated several internal reforms within the physical planning directorate in respect to processing development plan approvals. This is line with the government policy of promoting “ease of doing business”. Here, we have since reduced the turnaround time (from plan submission to approval) for building plans from the statutory 30 days to a mere 14 days or less if all building conditions are met at the time of submission.
To further realize this, we have initiated an on-line ‘Smart Permit’ solution, which is intended to enable any one intending to build/construct, renovate, excavate or demolish their properties to apply and process their permits online without having to interface with KCCA staff.
This in a way is envisaged— and shall help— to fast track our service delivery to a shorter time by way of reducing the lengthy and bureaucratic tendencies which may at times be characterized by corruption and other related malpractices.
Further, under my tenure we successfully rolled out the CAM/CAMV Project (City Address Model) under which we have done property valuation/house numbering as well as street naming in the entire city for the first time in very many years of its existence. Unfortunately, there is still rampant vandalism which always targets some of our new signage put out there.
Indeed, I am happy to tell Ugandans that this exercise has been very successful and was made possible with the support from the GoU/World Bank. Other projects include property evaluation, road improvement, beautification and signalization of selected traffic junctions.
SO: What is your next move, in case COSASE throws you out the job?
AMK: Well, we shall wait to see about that…., but in any case I am not a fugitive by any definition. I have only been at KCCA for the last seven years, so you cannot possibly think that I have made my life at KCCA, there are quite a number of options at my disposal. The KCCA job is and should not be a do or die. But in the meantime, I have instructed my lawyers to carefully follow the developments about this fracas.
SO: Thank you
AMK: It’s my pleasure.